A couple of weeks ago, I was just cleaning up after dinner when our doorbell rang. At the door was a sizable teenager - I could only guess his age by how he was speaking, rapidly and nervously reciting a
spiel about scholarship money and Chicago Tribune newspaper sales and
wouldyouhelpmebysubscribingforjusttwentydollars? We already have a subscription, so I asked if I could just make a donation. He said that would be fine, he'd just mark on my receipt that it was just that so we wouldn't get billed by the paper.
A receipt? Great. This is totally legit!
As I went to get my wallet, I thought of a few other people who had told me about similar experiences, where a teenager comes to their door at dinnertime with something to sell or a charity to support. Typically the message is, 'this is a scam - do not give them money.' For some reason, I ignored that thought and handed over $20, thinking it was better than giving him a personal check with our information on it. He then asked me for my mailing address so he could write it on the order form, so I gave it to him, and got a little nervous, wondering if I should even do that. But then, I realized, all he has to do is look at our address on our house - he's standing on my front porch, after all - to get that information. He was really polite, very appreciative and smiled and waved at Eamon. He handed me the receipt and walked off down the block to the next house. I looked down at the receipt as I shut the door and noticed that it had no information on it regarding a scholarship - it just had the Chicago Tribune logo, no indication that it was for a charity of any kind. I mumbled to myself, "idiot." And left the receipt on the table.
When my husband got home, he too agreed it was probably a scam because the receipt looked shady. Then he suggested I not answer the door when I'm home by myself at night, because anyone could just burst through the door. I thought of how big the kid was - he was built like a linebacker - and eventually lost about three hours of sleep that night thinking about how stupid I was for even opening the door and putting Eamon and myself in harm's way. I am a naive suburbanite, I thought, wondering where and when I'd lost my street smarts. I very rarely if ever give to panhandlers. I used to always deny those kids selling M&Ms on the street corners who say they're raising money for their basketball teams. Why would I give twenty bucks to a teenager on my front porch? I should have just turned the porch light off and ignored him.
Today in the mail I got a letter from the Chicago Tribune and a check for $20 from an organization called Starr E. Sales Inc. The message on the form letter said they apologized, but their records show I already have a subscription and therefore cannot subscribe through that charity. So, the kid was trustworthy, he just didn't have his information straight -- donations weren't allowed, only new subscriptions were accepted. I was glad I initially went with my gut and trusted him, and embarrassed that I thought he might have been a threat, and wonder now how many kids I've turned down who were honestly trying to raise money for something worthwhile. I'm a little sorry I wasn't able to support him in the end.
But I am still looking for my misplaced street smarts.